jackie onassis @ grand central (emotions via britney spears)

75 JO grand cent 634x970 and i realized i’ve just totally glossed over the father leonard letters as though they never happened, but they bring up all manner of biographical/historical/ethical brouhaha so i’ma pretend just a little longer like that’s not a pressing thing we need to discuss.

hey, instead, let’s talk about how grand central is recognizing jackie. and let’s use britney to get in touch with our emotions.

dancing brit

so the daily mail‘s article is surprisingly subdued (especially given how, simultaneous to this, a man with a tattoo of richard nixon on his back has come forward to say that tennessee williams told him that jackie spurned nixon’s advances.) but here’s the plaque…

and here’s the foyer renamed for jackie…

moving, obvi.

giphy

but, wait. let’s go back to that plaque.

britney-confused1

first, big huzzah to the image being of 70s jackie.

yes

obviously, i’m all for that as it’s both period appropriate (the fight to save grand central went down in 1975) and delightfully subverts the posthumous rehabilitation that suggests only jackie’s kennedy years are of use to us. so yay the 70s!

tumblr_maaf055zRm1r3ty02o1_500

but, as for the artistic merits of the portrayal, what do we make of that?

gifney5

there aren’t a lot of angles, but here’s another…

it is, how shall i say…

1713

kind of INCREDIBLY SPOOKY, non?!

from this angle. maybe there are other angles to which we’re not privy where it looks a bit less ghoulish, a bit less like she’s 5,000 years old.

(dear people of new york, get thee down there and send me pics!)

tumblr_meaxs66jLx1rvkbyno1_500

dare i hope she looks maybe even bit warmer? more like this:

2ca23ae843cd54cc_111626827_10.preview_tall

tumblr_mb34o1c8eb1rgznzdo1_500

or even more like the image on which the plaque appears to be loosely based…

which is, let’s be real, quite lovely. look at that twinkle in her eye. the hint of naughtiness.

then look at this:

jackie plaque

WHOA.

britneyspears

britfacials6

gifney23

why is jackie so serious?! so soulless??? can people on plaques not appear to be having fun?

tumblr_misvw3v3m41r3ty02o1_500

this is the face of the woman who saved grand central. it’s a joyous thing to have done. why is she so grim?

jackie plaque

giphy (1)

i’m not at all certain, though i do wonder if it doesn’t point to the idea that there are instances where we can acknowledge her post-JFK life because it is a necessity- for it would’ve been terribly anachronistic to have reverted to the standard portrayal…

article-2493731-194BBBA100000578-888_634x625
in this context- but, within that acknowledgement, she must be kept in her proper place.

she must remain sad and be appropriately mournful. heaven forbid she have joy.

tumblr_m412ppSn2X1r34pqeo1_r1_1280

this is a gross misrepresentation because she was, i think, often happy and this is, in part, a huge element of the endurance of her image: the fact that she represents survival and transformation. using the image to focus solely on the sadness brutally distorts the life.

Britgif_zps7ff668ac

looking at the 70s incarnation of her, when she first appeared on that women’s history handout i received in 6th grade, her joyousness was what struck me. she looked so different from all the other women on offer- because she was far more modern, yes, but also because she smiled. lookit…

Screen shot 2014-07-01 at 12.09.18 PM
who would you want to read more about here?

how sad to see that, as she passes deeper into our history (and the placement of a plaque in your honor commemorating something you did 40 years ago is a historicizing act if ever there was one), we’re taking that away.

britney sad

we’re putting her up there on that wall for all time immortalized as a stern, scary woman who looks more like christopher walken than herself.

how bold it would be to sneak the joy back in…

britney claps

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s